Most takes by culturally Christian atheists about Judaism are just not accurate. It’s unfortunate because I don’t see my own culture as infallible and I like getting goyishe perspectives on it. It just annoys me when they assume it’s just like Christianity without the New Testament because that’s not true. If you’re going to criticize, please do research first.
EDIT: Changed “non-Jewish” to “culturally Christian” for the sake of specificity.